Back to Civil Parties

clint

Civil Cases involving this party

Case History (59)

ALISON MCCLINTOCK v UK INSURANCE LIMITED

Reference: 26/051955
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 4
Date: 2 November 2026
Time: 10:30
Type: CIVIL BILLS FOR HEARING
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

BROOKE MCCLINTOCK v AXA INSURANCE DAC

Reference: 26/036945
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 26 October 2026
Time: 10:30
Type: CIVIL BILLS FOR HEARING
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 22 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Proof - First allowed diet
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

Michael Clinton v Grace Baugh

Reference: KIL-F214-24
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: SheriffS Fraser M
Courtroom: null
Date: 21 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Proof - Second or subsequent day
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

Clint Eastwood v A Din

Reference: 1774434163820528
Court: Skipton County Court and Family Court
Judge: District Judge Skalskyj-Reynolds
Courtroom: Skipton Courtroom 02
Date: 20 October 2026
Time: 10am
Type: Trial (Specified Money Claim)
Case Type: Small Claims
Location: In Person

Michael Clinton v Grace Baugh

Reference: KIL-F214-24
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: SheriffS Fraser M
Courtroom: null
Date: 19 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Proof - Second or subsequent day
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: McIntosh McCann Family & Civil Solicitors

HOLMES AND CLINTON-SMITH V CARTER AND WEST BAY INSURANCE PLC

Reference: CIV-2
Court: Birmingham Civil and Family Justice Centre
Judge: Birmingham CJC Hearing Room 116 (Floor 1): District Judge S Mansfield
Courtroom: null
Date: 14 October 2026
Time: 11:30am
Type: Costs and Case Management Conference
Case Type: General Application
Location: In Person

AOIFE MARIE MCSORLEY(MINOR) A MINOR BY RONAN ROBERT MCSORLEY HER FATHER AND NEXT FRIEND v KENNETH MCCLINTOCK, DOREEN MCCLINTOCK & STEVEN PAUL

Reference: 26/042356
Court: NI - DOWNPATRICK COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 3
Date: 13 October 2026
Time: 10:00
Type: For Approval
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: DOWNPATRICK COURTHOUSE

Jordan Adams v Kerry Clinton

Reference: AIR-F297-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Livingston D
Courtroom: null
Date: 8 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Moss & Kelly Solicitors

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 8 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Thompson Family Law

Donald MacDonald v Lynn Clinton or MacDonald

Reference: STO-F18-23
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 5 October 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The MacIver Teale Law Practice Ltd

North Lanarkshire Council v Andrew McLinton

Reference: AIR-SD80-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: SheriffS McKenna S
Courtroom: null
Date: 29 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: North Lanarkshire Council

ISLA ROSE FEENAN(MINOR) A MINOR BY FRANCYNE MCCLINTON HER MOTHER AND NEXT FRIEND v MICHAEL CARVILL

Reference: 26/056655
Court: NI - ARMAGH COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 25 September 2026
Time: 10:00
Type: MINOR PETITIONS
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: ARMAGH COURTHOUSE

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 24 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The MFY Partnership

Aberdeen City Council v Clinton Westlake-Tritton

Reference: ABE-SD304-25
Court: Aberdeen Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff M Bovey KC
Courtroom: null
Date: 18 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Recall of Decree Hearing
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: Aberdeen City Council

DAVID ROBERT MCCLINTOCK v MICHELIN TYRE LIMITED COMPANY, AEI LTD, GEC LTD & GEC ALSTHOLM TURBINE GENERATORS LTD

Reference: 25/038459
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 16 September 2026
Time: 10:30
Type: CIVIL BILLS FOR HEARING
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

David Njoku v Baldelectrician Limited t/a abc Electrical (director Stewart McLintock)

Reference: KIL-SG198-25
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Duguid KC
Courtroom: null
Date: 11 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Simple Procedure Hearing - First allowed diet
Case Type: Simple Procedure
Location: In Person

Lee McLintock v Andrina Condie + others

Reference: AIR-F249-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Haran P
Courtroom: null
Date: 10 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

Yorkshire Building Society t/a Chelsea Building Society v Andrew Clinton + others

Reference: HAM-B27-26
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 8 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: Irwin Mitchell

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 7 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Thompson Family Law

South Lanarkshire Council v Elizabeth McClinton

Reference: HAM-AW145-20
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 7 September 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Lunny & Co

THOMAS CLINTON HAMILTON v SABRE INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED

Reference: 25/077222
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 7 September 2026
Time: 10:30
Type: CIVIL BILLS FOR HEARING
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

Lee McLintock v Andrina Condie + others

Reference: AIR-F249-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Haran P
Courtroom: null
Date: 27 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

David Njoku v Baldelectrician Limited t/a abc Electrical (director Stewart McLintock)

Reference: KIL-SG198-25
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: SheriffS Lynch S
Courtroom: null
Date: 21 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Discussion in Court
Case Type: Simple Procedure
Location: In Person

Ciara Chittick or Beattie + others v Clinton Bain

Reference: KIL-F236-26
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Pettigrew C.
Courtroom: null
Date: 19 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Opposed Motion Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Matthew Brown Solicitors

Donald MacDonald v Lynn Clinton or MacDonald

Reference: STO-F18-23
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 10 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The MacIver Teale Law Practice Ltd

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 10 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

MARK MCKENZIE v KERRY CLINTON

Reference: GLW-F510-24
Court: Glasgow Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 4 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Thompson Family Law

South Lanarkshire Council v Elizabeth McClinton

Reference: HAM-AW145-20
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 3 August 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Lunny & Co

North Lanarkshire Council v Andrew McLinton

Reference: AIR-SD80-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Livingston D
Courtroom: null
Date: 21 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: North Lanarkshire Council

DHL International (UK) Limited v CLINTS FOOTWEAR LIMITED

Reference: CIV-19
Court: Manchester Civil Justice Centre
Judge: Before Judge
Courtroom: Manchester CJC Courtroom 16: District Judge Matharu
Date: 21 July 2026
Time: 10am
Type: Winding Up Petitions
Case Type: Insolvency and Companies
Location: In Person

LEE PENSON V SAMANTHA THACKRAY AND SUSAN CLINTON

Reference: L00PO497
Court: Worthing County Court and Family Court
Judge: Deputy District Judge Collins
Courtroom: Worthing Courtroom 05
Date: 20 July 2026
Time: 2pm
Type: Directions Hearing (Civil)
Case Type: Money Claims - Small Claim
Location: In Person

Jordan Adams v Kerry Clinton

Reference: AIR-F297-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Haran P
Courtroom: null
Date: 16 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The Cumbernauld Law Practice

Charlotte Craigens and others v Clinton House Strathclyde (Care Homes) Limited and another

Reference: COS/A234-22
Court: Court of Session
Judge: Lady Haldane
Courtroom: null
Date: 16 July 2026
Time: 10:30 AM
Type: Case Management Hearing
Case Type: Session Civil
Location: Levy and McRae Solicitors LLP / Clyde and Co (Scotland) LLP

Yorkshire Building Society t/a Chelsea Building Society v Andrew Clinton + others

Reference: HAM-B27-26
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Speir J
Courtroom: null
Date: 14 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: Irwin Mitchell

Donald MacDonald v Lynn Clinton or MacDonald

Reference: STO-F18-23
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 13 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: MacDonald Maciver & Company Limited

Michael Clinton v Grace Baugh

Reference: KIL-F214-24
Court: Kilmarnock Sheriff Court
Judge: SheriffS Fraser M
Courtroom: null
Date: 10 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Proof - Second or subsequent day
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

Carol Ann McClintock or Evans v Hannah Evans

Reference: LIV-AW18-23
Court: Livingston Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 10 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Caesar & Howie

James McLintock + others v Natasha McLintock + others

Reference: PER-F266-20
Court: Perth Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 6 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Proof - First allowed diet
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: McCash & Hunter LLP

James McLintock + others v Natasha McLintock + others

Reference: PER-F266-20
Court: Perth Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 1 July 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: McCash & Hunter LLP

Carol Ann McClintock or Evans v Hannah Evans

Reference: LIV-AW18-23
Court: Livingston Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 29 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others v Steven Clinton

Reference: STO-F21-25
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 29 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Full Case Management Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The MFY Partnership

Aberdeen City Council v Clinton Westlake-Tritton

Reference: ABE-SD304-25
Court: Aberdeen Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Wallace I
Courtroom: null
Date: 26 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: First Calling
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: Aberdeen City Council

DAVID ROBERT MCCLINTOCK v MICHELIN TYRE LIMITED COMPANY, AEI LTD, GEC LTD & GEC ALSTHOLM TURBINE GENERATORS LTD

Reference: 25/038459
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 24 June 2026
Time: 09:30
Type: TO BE MENTIONED
Case Type: HEARING LOSS CASES
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

South Lanarkshire Council v Elizabeth McClinton

Reference: HAM-AW145-20
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Speir J
Courtroom: null
Date: 22 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Lunny & Co

KERRY MCCLINTOCK v AXA INSURANCE DAC (2 Hours)

Reference: 23/062431
Court: NI - ANTRIM COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 19 June 2026
Time: 10:00
Type: CIVIL BILLS FOR HEARING
Case Type: CIVIL COURT
Location: ANTRIM COURTHOUSE

James McLintock + others v Natasha McLintock + others

Reference: PER-F266-20
Court: Perth Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Wood WM
Courtroom: null
Date: 17 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Pre-Proof Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: In Person

MARK MCKENZIE v KERRY CLINTON

Reference: GLW-F510-24
Court: Glasgow Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 16 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Thompson Family Law

Donald MacDonald v Lynn Clinton or MacDonald

Reference: STO-F18-23
Court: Stornoway Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Lamont G
Courtroom: null
Date: 15 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: The MacIver Teale Law Practice Ltd

North Lanarkshire Council v Andrew McLinton

Reference: AIR-SD80-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Unallocated
Courtroom: null
Date: 9 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Incidental Application Hearing
Case Type: Summary Cause
Location: North Lanarkshire Council

Bromsgrove School v Clint & Ritchie

Reference: M6GR6V5F
Court: Dudley County Court
Judge: Deputy District Judge P Davies
Courtroom: Dudley Courtroom 03
Date: 9 June 2026
Time: 10:00am-11:30am
Type: Application to set Judgment aside
Case Type: General Application
Location: In Person

South Lanarkshire Council v Elizabeth McClinton

Reference: HAM-AW145-20
Court: Hamilton Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff KF McCallum KC
Courtroom: null
Date: 8 June 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Lunny & Co

Clinton Properties & Estates Ltd V Mr Anthony Marr

Reference: N0PP6321
Court: St Helens County Court and Family Court
Judge: Deputy District Judge Henley
Courtroom: St Helens County Courtroom 05
Date: 1 June 2026
Time: 2:45pm
Type: Possession Rent (Private)
Case Type: Possession
Location: In Person

ELIZABETH ELAINE RYAN v BAILIE SCOTT MCCLINTON

Reference: 26/018944
Court: NI - ANTRIM COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 3
Date: 27 May 2026
Time: 10:30
Type: DISPUTED SMALL CLAIMS
Case Type: SMALL CLAIMS
Location: ANTRIM COURTHOUSE

JACK MCCLINTON v IQUW SYNDICATE MANAGEMENT LIMITED

Reference: 25/048204
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 26 May 2026
Time: 09:45
Type: 09:45
Case Type: REVIEW COURT COUNTY COURT JUDGE
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

DAVID ROBERT MCCLINTOCK v MICHELIN TYRE LIMITED COMPANY, AEI LTD, GEC LTD & GEC ALSTHOLM TURBINE GENERATORS LTD

Reference: 25/038459
Court: NI - LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE
Judge: null
Courtroom: COURT 2
Date: 21 May 2026
Time: 10:00
Type: 10:00
Case Type: CCJ COR DEFAULT CALLOVER
Location: LAGANSIDE COURTHOUSE

Lee McLintock v Andrina Condie + others

Reference: AIR-F249-25
Court: Airdrie Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Haran P
Courtroom: null
Date: 21 May 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Full Case Management Hearing
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Baker Gostelow Family Law

MARK MCKENZIE v KERRY CLINTON

Reference: GLW-F510-24
Court: Glasgow Sheriff Court
Judge: Sheriff Guy J
Courtroom: null
Date: 19 May 2026
Time: 10:00 AM
Type: Review of Sist
Case Type: Civil - Ordinary Actions
Location: Thompson Family Law

Clinton vs Clinton

Reference: CIV-1
Court: Preston Magistrates' Court
Judge: Before Judge
Courtroom: Preston Magistrates' Courtroom 04: District Judge Brown
Date: 5 March 2026
Time: 10am
Type: FR - FDR
Case Type: Financial Dispute
Location: In Person

Related Parties

A Din

Involved in civil proceedings

ALISON MCCLINTOCK

Involved in civil proceedings

AXA INSURANCE DAC

Involved in civil proceedings

AXA INSURANCE DAC (2 Hours)

Involved in civil proceedings

Aberdeen City Council Government

Involved in civil proceedings

Andrew Clinton + others

Involved in civil proceedings

Andrew McLinton

Involved in civil proceedings

Andrina Condie + others

Involved in civil proceedings

BAILIE SCOTT MCCLINTON

Involved in civil proceedings

BROOKE MCCLINTOCK

Involved in civil proceedings

Baldelectrician Limited t/a abc Electrical (director Stewart McLintock) Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Bromsgrove School

Involved in civil proceedings

CARTER AND WEST BAY INSURANCE PLC Company

Involved in civil proceedings

CLINTS FOOTWEAR LIMITED Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Carol Ann McClintock or Evans

Involved in civil proceedings

Charlotte Craigens and others

Involved in civil proceedings

Ciara Chittick or Beattie + others

Involved in civil proceedings

Clint

Involved in civil proceedings

Clint Eastwood

Involved in civil proceedings

Clinton

Involved in civil proceedings

Clinton Bain

Involved in civil proceedings

Clinton House Strathclyde (Care Homes) Limited and another Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Clinton Properties

Involved in civil proceedings

Clinton Westlake-Tritton

Involved in civil proceedings

DAVID ROBERT MCCLINTOCK

Involved in civil proceedings

DHL International (UK) Limited Company

Involved in civil proceedings

David Njoku

Involved in civil proceedings

Donald MacDonald

Involved in civil proceedings

ELIZABETH ELAINE RYAN

Involved in civil proceedings

Elizabeth McClinton

Involved in civil proceedings

Estates Ltd Company

Involved in civil proceedings

GEC ALSTHOLM TURBINE GENERATORS LTD Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Grace Baugh

Involved in civil proceedings

HOLMES AND CLINTON-SMITH

Involved in civil proceedings

Hannah Evans

Involved in civil proceedings

IQUW SYNDICATE MANAGEMENT LIMITED Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Irene MacDonald or Clinton + others

Involved in civil proceedings

JACK MCCLINTON

Involved in civil proceedings

James McLintock + others

Involved in civil proceedings

Jordan Adams

Involved in civil proceedings

KENNETH MCCLINTOCK, DOREEN MCCLINTOCK

Involved in civil proceedings

KERRY CLINTON

Involved in civil proceedings

KERRY MCCLINTOCK

Involved in civil proceedings

Kerry Clinton

Involved in civil proceedings

LEE PENSON

Involved in civil proceedings

Lee McLintock

Involved in civil proceedings

Lynn Clinton or MacDonald

Involved in civil proceedings

MARK MCKENZIE

Involved in civil proceedings

MICHAEL CARVILL

Involved in civil proceedings

MICHELIN TYRE LIMITED COMPANY, AEI LTD, GEC LTD Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Michael Clinton

Involved in civil proceedings

Mr Anthony Marr

Involved in civil proceedings

Natasha McLintock + others

Involved in civil proceedings

North Lanarkshire Council Government

Involved in civil proceedings

Ritchie

Involved in civil proceedings

SABRE INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED Company

Involved in civil proceedings

SAMANTHA THACKRAY AND SUSAN CLINTON

Involved in civil proceedings

STEVEN PAUL

Involved in civil proceedings

South Lanarkshire Council Government

Involved in civil proceedings

Steven Clinton

Involved in civil proceedings

THOMAS CLINTON HAMILTON

Involved in civil proceedings

UK INSURANCE LIMITED Company

Involved in civil proceedings

Yorkshire Building Society t/a Chelsea Building Society

Involved in civil proceedings